top of page
Search

What Counts as Family Violence?

8 hours ago
6 min read

Is every act of anger, rudeness or even violence in a family automatically "family violence" under the Family Law Act? It is a question that comes up in almost every contested parenting case, and the answer matters, because findings of family violence can shape where children live and how they spend time with each parent.


On 13 November 2026, in Cannon & Moore [2026] FedCFamC1A 206, five judges of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, led by Chief Justice Alstergren, gave a clear answer. Behaviour is only "family violence" under the Act if it coerces or controls a family member, or causes them to be fearful. The Court said parts of an earlier appeal decision, Pickford & Pickford, which suggested otherwise were "plainly wrong". The father's appeal was allowed and the case was sent back for a rehearing, but the existing parenting orders stay in place in the meantime.


Paper-cut illustration of a magnifying glass over a family home, showing a phone location pin, a padlocked wallet and an angry speech bubble, in front of a judge's bench and scales of justice, for an article on the legal definition of family violence.

In short


  • Under section 4AB(1) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), family violence has two parts: violent, threatening or other behaviour, and an effect, namely coercion, control or fear.

  • Violent, threatening or other behaviour alone will not satisfy the definition. The effect must also be established.

  • Statements in Pickford & Pickford (2024) suggesting family violence can include behaviour that neither coerces, controls nor causes fear were held to be "plainly wrong". The Court said that, in all other respects, the majority judgments in Pickford remain accurate and useful statements of the law.

  • The effect-based test can also capture seemingly minor behaviour that takes on far greater significance when its effect (coercion, control or fear) is considered.

  • Judges must say which disputed allegations they accept and which they reject. A general statement that both parents' allegations "constitute family violence" is not enough.

  • The appeal was allowed and the case was sent back for rehearing. The parenting orders, including supervised time, remain in force until then.


What happened in this case?


The parents separated after one of their two children made a disclosure to the child welfare department in Victoria. An intervention order was later made by consent, without admissions, and the father later breached it. At trial, the children were living with their mother and spending professionally supervised time with their father.


The father wanted joint decision-making and a gradual increase in time, leading to a week-about arrangement. The mother sought sole decision-making, with the children living with her and supervised time with the father. The Independent Children's Lawyer supported the mother's proposal.


The mother relied on a long list of alleged behaviour, including angry and abusive comments, financially controlling conduct, stopping payment of health insurance, household bills and a child's swimming lessons without notice, and using an app to monitor her movements. Some allegations were of physical violence. The father made some partial concessions, but said much of the insulting language was mutual conflict.


In June 2026 the trial judge ordered that the children live with the mother, that she have sole decision-making responsibility, and that the father's time with the children be supervised. The father, who represented himself, appealed.


Why did the appeal succeed?


The Court accepted two related complaints.


The reasons did not say which allegations were proved. The trial judge set out the mother's allegations in detail but did not adequately explain which were established and which were not. He said that "allegations made by both parents ... constitute family violence" without making findings about specific events. The Court said a party reading a judgment is entitled to know which allegations have been accepted and which have been rejected. Because the unresolved history of alleged violence was implicitly part of the reason for supervised time, this was an error.


The definition of family violence needed to be applied properly. The Court used one example to explain this. The mother described an incident in which, she said, the father swung his fist at her face, and she described the fear she felt. The Court said that evidence describes both the act and the effect. If it were accepted, it would plainly meet the definition. But the trial judge made no explicit finding about it, and did not explain why the mother's account was rejected, if it was.


What does "family violence" now mean?


Section 4AB(1) of the Family Law Act defines family violence as "violent, threatening or other behaviour by a person that coerces or controls a member of the person's family ... or causes the family member to be fearful".


The Court explained that the definition has two parts. First, there must be violent, threatening or other behaviour. Second, that behaviour must coerce or control a family member, or cause them to be fearful. The word "that" works as a qualifier. Only behaviour with one of those effects meets the definition.


The Court rejected the approach in parts of Pickford that would have allowed family violence to include behaviour with none of those effects. It gave the example used in Pickford of a punch that neither coerced, controlled nor caused fear, and said this falls short of the statutory definition, "and deliberately so". The Court explained that Parliament chose this effect-based definition largely on the recommendation of the Australian and NSW Law Reform Commissions.


The Court also made several points that matter in practice:


  • Not criminal law. The family law definition looks at the nature and effect of the behaviour within the family relationship. Criminal law ideas such as "assault" and intention can be unhelpful.

  • Intent is not required. Behaviour can be coercive or controlling, or cause fear, even if the person did not intend that effect.

  • Feeling coerced is not enough on its own. A person may feel coerced or controlled, but the judge must objectively find that the behaviour was coercive or controlling.

  • The examples are only examples. The list of behaviours in section 4AB(2), such as assault, is a list of things that "may constitute" family violence. An assault can meet the definition, but may not do so in every case.

  • Other conduct still counts. Conduct that does not meet the definition can still be relevant to what is in a child's best interests.


Why does the effect matter?


The Court pointed out that the Law Reform Commissions saw two advantages in an effect-based definition. First, it brings in seemingly innocuous or minor events that take on far greater significance when you look at their effect: coercion, control or fear. Second, it excludes events such as violent resistance by a victim. The definition looks at context.


The practical message is about evidence. If you allege family violence, the court needs evidence not only of what happened, but of its effect, such as fear, coercion or control. If you are responding to allegations, the question is not only whether something happened, but what it did within the relationship.


What orders did the Court make?


  1. The appeal was allowed.

  2. The trial judge's orders of 19 June 2026 remain in force.

  3. The case was sent back to a judge of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 1) for rehearing.

  4. Both parents received costs certificates under the Federal Proceedings (Costs) Act 1981 (Cth) for the appeal and the rehearing.

  5. The Independent Children's Lawyer's application for costs was refused.


The Court did not decide whether the father's conduct was or was not family violence. It also said a differently constituted court could still find that the evidence establishes a significant number of the facts the mother alleged. The children continue to live with their mother and to spend supervised time with their father until the rehearing.


The judgment uses pseudonyms, and family law proceedings are subject to strict publication restrictions. This article omits identifying details about the children and family. The case is discussed only for its legal significance.


Practical steps if family violence is an issue in your parenting case


  • Describe the effect, not just the incident. If you have experienced family violence, tell your lawyer how the behaviour affected you, for example whether it made you afraid or controlled what you could do.

  • Keep records. Messages, bank statements, notes made at the time and reports to police or doctors can help show both what happened and its effect.

  • Responding to allegations? Get advice early. The court will look at the full context of the behaviour, including any explanation you give.

  • Supervised time. In this case, the existing orders, including supervised time, stay in force until the rehearing, even though the father's appeal succeeded.


For more on parenting cases, see our parenting matters page and our guide to family reports in parenting matters.


How Surge Legal can help


Our family law team in Parramatta advises parents on parenting orders, family violence allegations and appeals.


To arrange a free initial consultation, call (02) 8551 7851, email info@surgelegal.com.au or book online.



Case: Cannon & Moore [2026] FedCFamC1A 206 (Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 1) Appellate Jurisdiction, 13 November 2026) This article is a general summary of the decision cited above for information purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice. Every case turns on its own facts. Please contact Surge Legal to discuss your individual circumstances.

bottom of page