top of page
Search

A Court of Law, Not a Tennis Court.

2h
5 min read

"This is a Court of law. It is not a tennis court on which wealthy, self-entitled litigants conduct their litigation as if it were merely sport, thereby distracting the Court from hearing other cases, and consuming an important, limited and valuable public resource."


That is how Justice Tom Altobelli AM opened his reasons in one of the recent judgements in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 1). Whilst we are huge tennis fans at Surge Legal, we understand perfectly well that family law should never be turned into an ego battleground between the litigants. Unfortunately, this is exactly what happened in this case.


We must note that Justice Altobelli is one of our all-time favourite family court judges. Before joining the bench in 2006 — and being elevated to the Family Court (now Division 1) in Sydney in 2020 — he practised family law for 25 years and was accredited by the Law Society of NSW as a specialist in family law, children's law and mediation. He has also authored four books on family law and dispute resolution — including Family Law in Australia: Principles and Practice, which is one of our all time favourites at Surge Legal. He has an impeccable understanding of family law, is very courteous and respectful, and is always a pleasure to appear before for well-prepared legal practitioners.


When a judge known across the profession for patience and courtesy opens a judgment by declaring that the Court is not a tennis court for wealthy, self-entitled litigants — and closes by writing that "hopefully the palpable frustration of the Court exudes from the words in these reasons for judgment" — it is worth looking closely at why he said it, and what he meant.


Paper-cut illustration of a tennis court between a Chinese courthouse and an Australian courthouse, with a judge in the umpire's chair, a sealed legal document flying over the net and the scales of justice above, for an article on an anti-suit injunction in a family law property case.

Why did Justice Altobelli say it?


The rebuke did not come out of nowhere. It sat at the end of a long build-up of procedural conflict, overseas manoeuvring and two interim applications that Justice Altobelli dismissed outright.


Twelve (!!!) interim applications before the case even reached trial. The wife commenced property proceedings in December 2024. Since then, the parties had filed extensive material, including 12 interlocutory applications, and joined multiple third-party respondents, including a company joined in April 2026. Deadlines to agree on single experts had been extended repeatedly, and the parties remained unable to agree on single experts for Chinese properties and businesses. A 13-day final hearing had already been set down across two tranches in April and May 2027. As Justice Altobelli put it, "Significant judicial resources have been allocated to these proceedings to date", and the parties ought to be doing everything in their power to prepare for trial rather than fighting another interim skirmish.


A "disturbing" parallel lawsuit in China — and apparent indifference on both sides. In mid-2026, the joined company sued the wife, the husband and their child in a People's Court in China over Chinese real properties and obtained a default judgment against the wife on 10 July 2026. Justice Altobelli set out "several disturbing factors" underlying those events: it was unclear whether the judge in China had been told about the Australian proceedings, or about the wife's contention that the husband effectively controls the company, and he called it a "remarkable coincidence" that the company chose to litigate a long-standing issue so close to the Australian final hearing. Yet neither party's conduct in relation to the Chinese orders reassured the Court. He noted that the husband's failure to comply with the very order the company asked the Chinese court to make against him personally "suggests a high degree of indifference and nonchalance about the judgment", while the wife's indifference about whether she would apply to set the Chinese orders aside — despite claiming she lacked knowledge of the proceedings — was "bewildering" and "again suggests indifference and nonchalance about those proceedings". Despite all of that, both parties continued invoking the Australian court's jurisdiction for yet another round of litigation.



What did Justice Altobelli mean?


That opening sentence was not just a memorable turn of phrase. The judgement carried several clear messages about how the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia expects litigants and lawyers to use the court system.


1. The Court is a finite public resource, not a private arena. Every hearing day consumed by another interim skirmish between wealthy litigants — and what the Court described as "their respective proxies" — distracts the Court from hearing other families' cases. Once the wife's injunction bid failed on delay and discretion, Justice Altobelli explicitly declined to spend the Court's "limited time and resources" analysing every nuance of the company's legal arguments. Court time belongs to the public, not to whoever can afford to keep filing interim applications.


2. Discretionary injunctions will not rescue unexplained delay or tactical skirmishing. An anti-suit injunction is a discretionary remedy. Where a party has inexcusably delayed acting before an overseas judgment is entered, has not pursued the proper remedy of applying to set that judgment aside, and brings an interim application that may make little or no difference to a just and equitable property outcome at trial, the Court will refuse to step in. Justice Altobelli went so far as to observe that, in those circumstances, the wife's application was arguably as potentially an abuse of the Court's process as she contended the company's Chinese litigation was.


3. Dismissing an interim bid does not give anyone a free pass at trial. Justice Altobelli made clear that his concerns about the Chinese litigation were not findings against anyone — no findings were possible at an interlocutory stage, so the company remained entitled to its judgment for now, and whether the husband controls the company is a matter for determination at the final hearing. At the same time, his warning was unmistakable: at the 2027 final hearing, the Court will regard the circumstances of the company's Chinese judgment against the husband and wife as a relevant issue "deserving of the utmost scrutiny in cross-examination".


This was an interlocutory decision. The property case is set down for a final hearing in April and May 2027, where the issues about the company and the Chinese judgment are to be determined.


Practical lessons from the judgment


  • Use court time with discipline. Running repeated interlocutory applications or tactical skirmishes that do not materially advance the final outcome risks sharp judicial scrutiny and wasted legal costs.

  • Act before an overseas judgment is entered. If proceedings start overseas while your Australian property case is running, take steps promptly to protect your rights. Unexplained delay after notice was a decisive factor here.

  • Pursue the right remedy. The Court said that if the Chinese judgment concerned the wife, her appropriate remedy was to apply to set it aside.

  • Expect overseas manoeuvres to be tested at trial. Even where an interim restraint is refused, the Court signalled that the circumstances of the Chinese judgment will receive "the utmost scrutiny in cross-examination" at the final hearing.

  • Support maintenance claims with evidence. Here, the Court was not satisfied that weekly claims of $2,500 for food and household supplies and $2,000 for other commitments were reasonable without evidence.


For more information, see our family law and spousal maintenance pages. Our team also advises Mandarin-speaking clients; see our Chinese-language page.


How Surge Legal can help


Our family law team in Parramatta advises on property settlements involving overseas assets, interlocutory applications and spousal maintenance.


To arrange a free initial consultation, call (02) 8551 7851, email info@surgelegal.com.au or book online.



Case: Mihova & Mihova (No 7) [2026] FedCFamC1F 676 This article is a general summary of the decision cited above for information purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice. Every case turns on its own facts. Please contact Surge Legal to discuss your individual circumstances.

bottom of page