When Children's Wishes Aren't the Final Word: Astheimer & Astheimer
"My children say they don't want to spend time with their other parent. Won't the court just do what they want?" It is a question many separated parents ask. The short answer is no. The Family Law Act requires the court to consider any views a child expresses, but those views are one consideration among many, and the court will look closely at how they came to be formed.
In Astheimer & Astheimer [2026] FedCFamC1F 571, decided on 28 August 2026, Justice Strum of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 1) ordered that the two younger children of a separated couple live with each parent on a week-about basis, even though they had said they wanted to stay mainly with their mother. The Court found that the mother had "attempted, to some extent, to alienate the children" from their father, and that their views had been "influenced, and malignly so", by her.

In short
The court must consider any views expressed by the children, but those views do not decide the case. Here, the Court took the children's wishes into account and weighed them against the expert evidence and its findings about how those wishes had been formed.
The Court found that the children's views, especially those of the second child, had been influenced by the mother, and that without a change the second child was likely to follow the path of the eldest child, whose relationship with the father had broken down, with a risk that the youngest would follow too.
The Family Report writer had recommended reducing the father's time. In cross-examination, once the trial evidence was put to her, she largely resiled from those recommendations and supported the children ultimately living equally with both parents.
The two younger children moved from living mainly with their mother to equal time, starting immediately. The Court did not order the initial period with no time with the mother that the father had sought.
This is a first-instance decision on its own facts. It does not change the law, but it shows how influenced wishes are weighed.
What happened in this case?
The parents have three children. At the time of the judgment, the eldest child was 17 and the two younger children were 14 and 8. The parents agreed that the eldest child would live with the mother and spend time with the father as agreed between them, taking into account the eldest child's wishes. The eldest child's relationship with the father had broken down.
The dispute was about the two younger children. They were living mainly with the mother and spending five nights a fortnight with the father. The mother asked the Court to reduce the father's time to four nights a fortnight. The father asked for an initial period in which the children would not see the mother, followed by the children living mainly with him or, as an alternative, living week-about with each parent.
Property settlement and child support were resolved by consent orders on the third day of the trial, leaving the parenting arrangements and the mother's claim for spousal maintenance for the Court to decide.
What did the children want, and why did it not decide the case?
Both younger children expressed a wish to remain in their mother's primary care, the second child more strongly. Section 60CC(2)(b) of the Family Law Act requires the court to consider any views expressed by the children, and the Court did so.
But the Court also had to consider where those views came from. The Family Report writer had observed that the second child's account, while compelling, appeared somewhat imbalanced and was due in part to the emotional pressure of chronic parental conflict into which the child had been "triangulated". In cross-examination, she agreed it was difficult to know what that child's real views were.
The Court found that the mother was primarily, though not solely, responsible for that pressure. It found that the mother had been the children's primary caregiver before and since separation, but that this was partly because she had rebuffed the father's efforts to be more involved, and had caused the two older children to rebuff them too. The Family Report writer was unable to name a single instance in which the mother had taken an active step to support the children's relationship with their father.
Justice Strum took the children's wishes into account, but considered that, on the evidence of the parties and the Family Report writer, those views, especially in the second child's case, "have been influenced, and malignly so, by the wife".
Why did the Family Report writer change her view?
The Family Report writer's second report, completed in January 2026, recommended that the younger children continue to live with the mother and that the father's time be reduced from five to four nights a fortnight. That report was written before the parties filed their trial affidavits and amended applications.
Before she was cross-examined, the Court directed that she be given the parties' latest applications and proposed orders. When the evidence as it had unfolded at trial was put to her, she largely resiled from her recommendations. She said that if the Court found the mother's influence was destructive and was having a significant, long-standing negative impact on the children, she would support a week-about arrangement. The Court made that finding. She also agreed there were "features of an alienating course of conduct" on the mother's part.
The case is a reminder that a Family Report is important evidence, but it is not the final word. The report writer's opinion is tested at trial, and the judge decides what is in the children's best interests on all the evidence. For more on how these reports work, see our guide to family reports in parenting matters.
Was this "parental alienation"?
The Court did not make a diagnosis or describe a syndrome. Its finding was that the mother "has attempted, to some extent, to alienate the children from the husband", and that she had contributed to the breakdown of the eldest child's relationship with the father and to the difficulties in the second child's relationship with him. The Court did not accept that there was any need to "rescue" the children from the father.
The judgment was also balanced. The Court accepted that the father may have contributed to the problems, but found that the mother's conduct had contributed "to a far greater extent" than his.
For a broader explanation of how courts approach these situations, see our article on dealing with parental alienation.
Why week-about, despite the conflict?
Parents in high-conflict cases often assume that equal time is off the table because they cannot co-parent. Justice Strum addressed that directly: "it only takes one parent for two parents to be unable to co-parent and, if that were allowed to be so, equal time might never be ordered."
The Court relied on the Family Report writer's evidence that, even where parents cannot co-parent, week-about care can be a "simple arrangement" that works for school-aged children, and can help children test a one-sided narrative against their own experience of each parent. The Court accepted that moving from the mother's primary care to equal care would likely cause the children some distress in the short term, and said that, if so, the mother "should reflect upon her conduct since separation".
The Court also observed that parents should not expect the arrangements they had while married to continue automatically after separation.
The Family Report writer had suggested a short initial period with more time at the father's home before moving to equal time. The Court accepted that this would otherwise have been warranted, but decided against it because forthcoming holiday dates would have interrupted it, and it placed considerable weight on the writer's view that a "keep it simple" approach was best for these children. The Court also found that a period of no contact with the mother, as the father had proposed, would very likely compound the children's distress.
What orders did the Court make?
The parents have joint decision-making responsibility for major long-term issues about the children.
The eldest child lives with the mother and spends time with the father as the parents agree in writing, taking into account the eldest child's wishes.
During school terms, the two younger children live with each parent on an alternating week-about basis, starting with the father, with the change on Friday after school. The first week began immediately on the day the orders were made.
From the end of Term 4 in 2026, the younger children spend half of each school holiday period with each parent, with the order of the halves alternating each year.
The father was ordered to pay the mother spousal maintenance of $4,000 a month from 1 September 2026 to 31 December 2027. The Court said it would have ordered 12 months, but set the period at 16 months to take account of the time since the property orders were made, in place of an order for arrears.
The Court did not make the initial no-contact period the father had sought.
What does this mean for you?
Children's views matter, but so does how they were formed. The court will listen to what children say, and will also ask whether a parent has shaped those views.
Actively support the other relationship. The court looks at what each parent actually does to support the children's relationship with the other parent, including following court-ordered arrangements such as phone calls.
Keep children out of the dispute. In this case, the Court took into account pressure placed on a child about the arrangements and the child being drawn into the parents' conflict.
A Family Report is not the end of the story. Recommendations can change when the evidence is tested at trial.
Equal time is not ruled out by conflict alone. As this case shows, one parent's inability or unwillingness to co-parent will not necessarily prevent an order for equal time.
How Surge Legal can help
Our family law team in Parramatta advises parents on parenting orders, Family Reports and disputes about children's wishes. We advise and act for parents in parenting disputes, including disputes about a child's views and how those views came about.
To arrange a free initial consultation, call (02) 8551 7851, email info@surgelegal.com.au or book online.
Surge Legal was not involved in the reported proceedings. This article discusses a publicly available judgment, published under a pseudonym, for general legal information, and omits details that could identify the family.
Case: Astheimer & Astheimer [2026] FedCFamC1F 571 (Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 1), Strum J, 28 August 2026) This article is a general summary of the decision cited above for information purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice. Every case turns on its own facts. Please contact Surge Legal to discuss your individual circumstances.




